Finding the viola

TL;DRMost people can smell vanilla on its own but lose it in a glass of wine. I think finding one familiar aroma inside a complex wine is a trainable skill, and here's how I'm training it.

I know what a viola sounds like. Put one in a room by itself and I’ll recognize it. Put it in an orchestra and I lose it almost immediately. It’s still there, playing its line under the violins, but what I hear is “orchestra.”

Smell works the same way. Most people can pick out vanilla or lemon on its own without much trouble. Put a hint of either into a glass of wine, alongside fruit and flowers and oak and everything else, and most people smell “wine.” The note is in there. They just can’t follow it.

I think that’s a trainable skill, and I’ve been building a way to practice it with the friends I taste with. We call it Finding the Viola, and it opens some of the evenings in our tasting series.

What makes it work is splitting “I can’t pick out the aroma” into smaller skills. There are five we practice. Detection is noticing that something is different at all. Classification is placing it in a family: fruit, flowers, herbs, earth. Identification is naming it more specifically. Segmentation is picking out two aromas when they’re mixed together. Transfer is recognizing something related in an actual wine. Most tasting advice jumps straight to identification (“do you get the cherry?”), which is the hardest place to start and the easiest place to feel lost.

So each session climbs in the same order. We start with six references: culinary aromas added to a neutral, dry Pinot Grigio, next to an unmodified glass of the same wine. With the names visible, you smell the plain wine, then a reference, then the plain wine again. Then the labels disappear. The six come back in a different order, marked with Greek letters, and everyone writes down impressions before the reveal. “Floral” counts. “Red fruit” counts. Getting the family right is progress.

Next comes strength. One aroma, four glasses: an unmodified control, half strength, full strength and double strength. The first job is just to notice a difference, and only then to name it. The half-strength glass is where it gets interesting, because that’s much closer to how quietly an aroma actually shows up in wine.

Then mixtures. Three glasses, each with two references blended together. Usually one takes over and the other seems to vanish, and the exercise is to keep looking for both before anyone talks. Finally we reset and taste four wines, starting from our own observations with no aroma list in front of us. Only afterward do we ask whether anything familiar showed up.

Two design choices matter more than they look. The first is repetition. Across four evenings there are 24 reference appearances but only 17 distinct aromas, and that’s on purpose: mushroom comes back with Pinot, the Carso wines and the Jura; beeswax connects Chardonnay and Carso; green apple connects Chardonnay and the Jura. You don’t learn a voice by hearing it once. The second is that the references are analogies, not ingredients. Nobody is claiming the wine contains rosemary. “I don’t find it in this wine” is a perfectly good conclusion, and I’d rather hear that than watch someone talk themselves into a note because it’s on the list.

There’s also a real limit here, and it’s worth knowing. In a 1996 study, both trained panelists and professional perfumers could pick out only three or four components of a complex odor mixture, and training didn’t raise that number. So the goal isn’t to list twelve things in a glass. It’s closer to what a musician does: choose one line and follow it through the piece. That’s a smaller claim than “anyone can learn to taste like a sommelier,” and I think it’s the one that’s actually true.

We’re running these sessions over the coming evenings, and I’ll write up what changes, including if the answer is “not much.” If you want to try it with your own group, the method and a five-page attendee guide are on our tasting site. All you need is a neutral white, a few things from the kitchen, and the patience to smell the plain wine one more time.

Sources