Why I rebuilt our wine tastings around one question
TL;DRAfter a few years of tasting with friends, none of us, me included, had gotten much better at tasting. So I redesigned the evenings so each one answers a single question, with everything else held constant.
I’ve been hosting wine tastings with friends for a few years, and I’ve gone through several versions of how to run them.
The first version was a small group focused simply on learning about the wines of one region. We did the Rhône Valley that way, and then Piedmont. The second version was bigger, with larger groups organized around a grape or a question of value. We tasted Pinot Noir from around the world, and we ran a sparkling comparison built around whether Champagne is worth the extra money.
Those were good evenings, and I’d happily do any of them again. But a few years in, I noticed something that bothered me: the overall tasting level of the group hadn’t moved much. That included me. We’d tasted a lot of good wine. We weren’t much better at tasting it.
My read on why is that those formats changed too many things at once. A regional tasting varies producer, vintage, grape, site and winemaking in the same flight, so when two wines taste different, there’s no way to say what caused it. A grape tour across continents does the same thing on a bigger map. You come away with impressions, but nothing that trains you to connect a cause to what’s in the glass. And every evening was a one-off, so nothing came back around to be practiced.
So I designed a series where each evening exists to answer one question. It’s called A Cellar in Chapters: eighteen tastings, eight people, four wines a night, in three chapters. The first holds a single grape up to the light, the second traces a place through the glass, and the third crosses a border to see what survives the trip.
The questions are the point. For Syrah, we put two Pacific Northwest wines against Côte-Rôtie and Hermitage and asked whether Syrah’s personality is shaped more by place or by winemaking philosophy. For Riesling, three wines from the same producer, vineyard and 2017 vintage walk from Kabinett to Spätlese to Auslese, so sweetness is the thing that changes, and the question is when more of it improves balance and when it becomes too much. In the Jura, we’ll compare Savagnin that’s been topped up with Savagnin left to age under a veil of yeast. And one Pinot evening is fully blind, to see whether we end up grouping the wines by style or by where they’re from.
Wherever I can, the flight holds everything constant except the thing we’re asking about. That’s why Muscadet opens the running order: one grower, one grape, one vintage, and three different rocks underneath, so the ground is the only variable. If anyone at the table can taste terroir, that’s the evening to show it.
Some evenings also start with a short aroma exercise I’ve written about separately, Finding the viola, which practices picking out one familiar smell inside a complex wine. The two ideas fit together. The question gives each evening a reason to pay close attention, and the aroma work gives people a way to do it.
We’re one tasting in. Syrah came first, and Muscadet is next. It’s far too early to know whether the group is getting better, and I’m trying not to decide the answer in advance. But I’m excited about it, because this is the first version built specifically to make all of us better tasters.
If you run tastings with friends, the one change I’d suggest is to pick the question before you pick the bottles. Then find four wines where only one thing changes. The full series, with every flight and question, is on our tasting site.
Sources
- A Cellar in Chapters, series overview. https://wine.jessri.com/
- A Cellar in Chapters, “Syrah North and West: Rhône vs Washington.” https://wine.jessri.com/tastings/syrah-north-and-west/
- A Cellar in Chapters, “Riesling 2017: Dry to Auslese.” https://wine.jessri.com/tastings/riesling-2017/
- A Cellar in Chapters, “Topped Up or Left Alone: The Jura.” https://wine.jessri.com/tastings/jura/
- A Cellar in Chapters, “Pinot Without a Passport: Alto Adige vs Burgundy.” https://wine.jessri.com/tastings/pinot-without-a-passport/